The Toronto Maple Leafs have several forwards with varying levels of contract value.
One of the best value contracts belongs to Auston Matthews. Signed through the 2023-24 season with an average annual value (AAV) of $11.6 million, Matthews consistently delivers elite goal-scoring and offensive prowess, making his contract one of the team’s best investments.
Another standout is Mitch Marner, signed through 2024-25 with an AAV of $10.9 million. Marner’s playmaking ability and versatility add significant value, although some may debate whether his salary slightly exceeds his on-ice impact.
On the other end of the spectrum, there are contracts like John Tavares’. Signed through 2024-25 with an AAV of $11 million, Tavares has faced criticism for declining production relative to his salary, especially considering his role as a top-line center.
William Nylander’s contract is another topic of debate. Signed through 2023-24 with an AAV of $6.9 million, Nylander’s performance has varied, sometimes not meeting expectations set by his salary.
In summary, while Matthews and Marner provide strong value relative to their contracts due to their consistent high-level performances, Tavares and Nylander’s contracts are scrutinized more closely due to occasional inconsistencies or declining production. The team’s overall salary cap management remains a challenge as they aim to balance these contracts with the performance expectations of their forwards.
