Giants Fans Do Not Root for the Eagles Unless They Are Playing Dallas

Giants Fans Do Not Root for the Eagles Unless They Are Playing Dallas

The longstanding rivalries between the New York Giants, Philadelphia Eagles, and Dallas Cowboys have cultivated deep-seated animosities among their fan bases. For Giants supporters, the Eagles and Cowboys represent their most significant adversaries, making the prospect of choosing sides particularly challenging when these teams face off.

Historically, the Giants-Eagles rivalry has been intense and bitter. Since their first meeting in 1933, the two teams have clashed numerous times, with the Eagles currently leading the series 96–89–2. This fierce competition has fostered a mutual disdain between the fan bases, making it uncommon for Giants fans to support the Eagles under typical circumstances.

The rivalry with the Cowboys, which began in 1960, is equally storied. The Cowboys lead the series 77–47–2, and their matchups with the Giants often carry significant weight in divisional standings. The animosity toward Dallas is so profound that Giants fans might momentarily set aside their aversion to the Eagles when Philadelphia faces the Cowboys. In such cases, the sentiment is driven by a desire to see Dallas falter, even if it means rooting for another rival.

However, recent events have tested these traditional loyalties. Former Giants star Saquon Barkley joined the Eagles for the 2024–2025 season, leading Philadelphia to a Super Bowl victory. His success with a chief rival has been a bitter pill for many Giants fans to swallow, intensifying the internal conflict when choosing sides.

In essence, while Giants fans typically refrain from supporting the Eagles, the deep-seated rivalry with the Cowboys can prompt them to make exceptions, highlighting the complex dynamics of NFL fandom.